
Case study 02 · Industrial Manufacturing
Precision Manufacturing
Acquisition Screening.
A CNC machining business serving industrial and defense customers, offered at $1.5 million with real estate excluded. Strong reported margins; a financing structure that does not work for an owner-operator.
A · Executive overview
Healthy reported earnings, priced for a different kind of buyer.
The business offers CNC machining, multi-axis milling and related precision work to industrial and defense customers. It was established in 2010, current ownership dates from 2024, and a general manager is employed. An AS9100 audit is reported to be in progress.
It is offered at $1,500,000 against seller-reported revenue of $1,519,772, SDE of $374,570 and EBITDA of $260,245. The price includes stated equipment of $682,206 and inventory of $120,000. The property is owned separately and offered for about $1 million.
At a 25% SDE margin the business is profitable. The question is whether an owner-operator who must also pay themselves can carry the acquisition debt the price requires.
- Industry
- Precision manufacturing
- Location
- Upstate New York
- Established
- 2010 (ownership since 2024)
- Management
- General manager employed
- Transaction
- Business only; real estate excluded
- Seller motivation
- Relocation
- Included assets
- $682k equipment, $120k inventory
- Reporting period
- Not disclosed
Principal acquisition considerations
- Annual debt service of $249,155 against $148,531 of modeled cash.
- Occupancy cost is unresolved: a market lease could add about $104,000 a year.
- The $114,325 gap between SDE and EBITDA needs reconciliation.
- Defense-contract transferability and AS9100 status are unconfirmed.
B · Financial snapshot
What the listing reports.
Revenue
Reported$1,519,772
Seller-reported
Seller SDE
Reported$374,570
BizBuySell cash-flow field
EBITDA
Reported$260,245
Seller-reported
Asking price
Reported$1,500,000
As listed
Ask / SDE
Derived4.00x
Sector median 3.08x (sold)
Ask / EBITDA
Derived5.76x
On seller-reported EBITDA
The $114,325 difference between SDE and EBITDA implies broker-assumed management cost; it has not been reconciled.
C · Earnings & cash flow analysis
From reported SDE to an annual shortfall.
Annual, USD
Earnings bridge
View data table
| Step | Amount | Running total |
|---|---|---|
| Seller SDE | $374,570 | $374,570 |
| Screening haircut | ($46,821) | $327,749 |
| Adjusted SDE | $327,749 | $327,749 |
| Buyer comp | ($145,175) | $182,574 |
| Maintenance capex | ($34,043) | $148,531 |
| Cash for debt | $148,531 | $148,531 |
| Debt service | ($249,155) | ($100,624) |
| Annual shortfall | ($100,624) | ($100,624) |
D · Acquisition financing
An 85% SBA-financed structure with a standby seller note.
Capital structure
Sources and uses at the asking price
Uses of funds
$1,821,922
- Purchase price$1,500,000 · 82%
- Working capital$250,693 · 14%45-day collections plus half a month's revenue
- Closing costs$30,000 · 2%Legal, diligence, lender packaging
- SBA upfront fee$41,229 · 2%FY2027 tiers, financed
Sources of funds
$1,821,922
- SBA 7(a) loan$1,554,818 · 85%10.25%, 10-year amortisation
- Buyer cash equity$178,069 · 10%10% of project cost before fee
- Seller note$89,035 · 5%5%, full standby
View data table
| Item | Amount | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Use: Purchase price | $1,500,000 | 82.3% |
| Use: Working capital | $250,693 | 13.8% |
| Use: Closing costs | $30,000 | 1.6% |
| Use: SBA upfront fee | $41,229 | 2.3% |
| Source: SBA 7(a) loan | $1,554,818 | 85.3% |
| Source: Buyer cash equity | $178,069 | 9.8% |
| Source: Seller note | $89,035 | 4.9% |
Annual debt service
Derived$249,155
Matches the memorandum
Total uses
Derived$1,821,922
Recomputed on the memo's corrected fee basis
Buyer cash for 1.25x at ask
Derived$970,000
Memo estimate; SBA loan ~$742,000
Financing assumptions in detail
- Interest rate
- 10.25% with 10-year amortisation; illustrative, not a lender quote.
- Upfront fee
- FY2027 tiers, financed into the loan. The supplied workbook used a flat 3.25% × 75%; the memo corrects this.
- Equity and seller note
- 10% buyer equity and a 5% seller note on full standby for the loan term.
- Working capital
- $250,693: 45-day collections plus half a month's revenue as a cash reserve, after crediting included inventory. Screening estimates, not company figures.
- Closing costs
- $30,000 provisional budget: $15,000 legal, $10,000 financial diligence, $5,000 lender and valuation.
- Buyer compensation
- $145,175: Rochester production-manager median of $116,140 plus a 25% employer-cost allowance.
E · Debt-service coverage
Coverage of 0.60x, before rent is considered.
Cash for debt service ÷ annual debt service
Coverage against the screening threshold
View data table
| Scenario | Cash for debt service | Annual debt service | Coverage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seller SDE, no haircut | $195,352 | $249,155 | 0.78x |
| Base case | $148,531 | $249,155 | 0.60x |
| Downside | $82,981 | $249,155 | 0.33x |
F · Valuation & supportable price
A price inside the sector range that the financing cannot carry.
Seller SDE basis
Asking price in context
Comparison band 2.32x–4.23x reported earnings (median 3.08x)
Asking price as listed
Price the modeled financing can carry at 1.25x
View data table
| Reference | Value | Multiple of reported cash flow |
|---|---|---|
| Sector low (lower quartile) | $869,002 | 2.32x |
| Sector median | $1,153,676 | 3.08x |
| Sector high (upper quartile) | $1,584,431 | 4.23x |
| Seller asking price | $1,500,000 | 4.00x |
| Debt-supported ceiling | $569,000 | 1.52x |
BizBuySell machining and tooling benchmarks (sold businesses, 2021–2025) put the interquartile range at 2.32x–4.23x seller SDE, with a 3.08x median. At 4.00x, the ask is 30% above the median but inside the upper quartile.
The modeled financing supports about $569,000 at 1.25x. Across the working-capital scenarios that range is $506,000–$631,000, and $522,000 without the standby seller note.
A debt-supported ceiling is not fair market value. It measures what this financing structure can carry from modeled cash flow.
G · Scenario analysis
Four ways the deal could work, and what each requires.
These are the alternatives tested in the memorandum, shown as a static comparison. They assume occupancy costs are already reflected in earnings and remain conditional on diligence.
Static comparison: interactive controls are offered only where the full model has been validated (see Case 01).
Stated in the memorandum · static
Acquisition alternatives
| Scenario | Coverage | Ceiling / note |
|---|---|---|
| Base case at askOwner-operator, modeled structure | 0.60x | $569,000 |
| Favourable working capital$188,237 at close (30-day collections) | 0.62x | Ceiling range $506k–$631k across scenarios |
| Price renegotiationPurchase at ~$569,000 | 1.25x | Falls below 1.25x in the downside |
| Increased equity~$970,000 buyer cash, $742,000 SBA loan | 1.25x | Residual cash ~$29,700 (3.1% pre-tax on cash) |
| Strategic acquirerNo added management cost | 1.18x | $1,400,000$1.19M ceiling with $36,294 added management |
| Verified full SDE + strategic$374,570 substantiated | 1.37x | 1.07x after a 20% earnings decline |
| Remove haircut onlyOwner-operator | 0.78x |
H · Key investment risks
Where the uncertainty sits.
Status reflects documented screening flags: raised, not disclosed or clear. No numerical risk scores are assigned.
| Category | Screening status | Finding | Diligence required |
|---|---|---|---|
| Financing feasibility | Flag raised | Base DSCR of 0.60x against 1.25x, with an annual shortfall of $100,624. | Confirmed equity capacity and written lender terms before further spend. |
| Lease & occupancy | Flag raised | Real estate is owned separately; no incremental rent is modeled. A $6.50/sq ft benchmark implies ~$104,000 a year for 16,000 sq ft. | Proposed lease terms and occupancy costs already in the accounts. |
| Earnings quality | Not disclosed | Reporting period undisclosed; the $114,325 SDE-to-EBITDA gap is unexplained. | Three years of statements, tax returns and an SDE reconciliation. |
| Management dependency | Not disclosed | A GM manages operations; who holds customer relationships is unconfirmed. | Responsibility map, GM retention terms. |
| Customer concentration | Not disclosed | No customer-level revenue breakdown; defense awards may be bids rather than contracts. | Backlog, concentration and contract-transfer requirements. |
| Certification | Not disclosed | AS9100 is reported as an audit in progress, not complete. | Audit status and transferability of registrations. |
| Capital expenditure | Not disclosed | $682,206 of equipment at stated value; condition and age unknown. | Equipment register and replacement schedule. |
| Working capital | Not disclosed | Receivables are not explicitly included or excluded. | AR/AP ageing, WIP schedule, balances at close. |
| Valuation | No flag | 4.00x SDE sits inside the sector's upper quartile (4.23x), though 30% above the median. | No premium without evidence of contracted growth. |
Financing feasibility
Flag raisedBase DSCR of 0.60x against 1.25x, with an annual shortfall of $100,624.
Diligence: Confirmed equity capacity and written lender terms before further spend.
Lease & occupancy
Flag raisedReal estate is owned separately; no incremental rent is modeled. A $6.50/sq ft benchmark implies ~$104,000 a year for 16,000 sq ft.
Diligence: Proposed lease terms and occupancy costs already in the accounts.
Earnings quality
Not disclosedReporting period undisclosed; the $114,325 SDE-to-EBITDA gap is unexplained.
Diligence: Three years of statements, tax returns and an SDE reconciliation.
Management dependency
Not disclosedA GM manages operations; who holds customer relationships is unconfirmed.
Diligence: Responsibility map, GM retention terms.
Customer concentration
Not disclosedNo customer-level revenue breakdown; defense awards may be bids rather than contracts.
Diligence: Backlog, concentration and contract-transfer requirements.
Certification
Not disclosedAS9100 is reported as an audit in progress, not complete.
Diligence: Audit status and transferability of registrations.
Capital expenditure
Not disclosed$682,206 of equipment at stated value; condition and age unknown.
Diligence: Equipment register and replacement schedule.
Working capital
Not disclosedReceivables are not explicitly included or excluded.
Diligence: AR/AP ageing, WIP schedule, balances at close.
Valuation
No flag4.00x SDE sits inside the sector's upper quartile (4.23x), though 30% above the median.
Diligence: No premium without evidence of contracted growth.
I · Final investment assessment
Decline at the $1.5 million
asking price.
Adjusted SDE of $327,749 leaves $148,531 after buyer compensation and maintenance capex, against $249,155 of debt service: 0.60x coverage and an annual shortfall of $100,624. A further 20% earnings decline takes coverage to 0.33x.
Reported margins are healthy; the problem is structure. The business is priced closer to what a strategic acquirer with existing management could finance (1.18x at ask) than an owner-operator.
What would justify reconsideration: A substantial price reduction (toward ~$569,000), materially greater equity (about $970,000 of buyer cash), or verified earnings and management arrangements that support a strategic acquisition.
Required due diligence
- Three years of statements and tax returns; SDE reconciliation
- Proposed lease terms and existing occupancy costs
- Payroll records and GM retention terms
- Customer concentration, backlog and contract transfer
- Equipment condition and AS9100 status
Material unresolved assumptions
- Market rent for the separately owned premises
- Reporting period
- Receivables treatment at close
- Defense-contract transferability
Assessment basis: memorandum dated 9 November 2026 and the supplied screening workbook, with the memo's corrections to the guarantee fee and downside calculation. Not a quality-of-earnings assessment, independent valuation or lending approval.
J · Sample deliverables
What a client receives.
A public excerpt of the screening model: inputs, financing and outputs, each labelled by basis. Workbook formulas and internal tabs are not published.
| Section | Item | Value | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Listing | Asking price | 1,500,000 | Reported |
| Listing | Revenue | 1,519,772 | Reported |
| Listing | Seller SDE | 374,570 | Reported |
| Listing | EBITDA | 260,245 | Reported |
| Earnings | Screening haircut | 12.5% | Assumption |
| Earnings | Adjusted SDE | 327,749 | Derived |
| Earnings | Buyer compensation | 145,175 | Assumption |
| Earnings | Maintenance capex | 34,043 | Assumption |
| Earnings | Cash for debt service | 148,531 | Derived |
| Financing | Working capital | 250,693 | Assumption |
| Financing | Closing costs | 30,000 | Assumption |
| Financing | SBA upfront fee (FY2027) | 41,229 | Derived |
| Financing | SBA 7(a) loan | 1,554,818 | Derived |
| Outputs | Annual debt service | 249,155 | Derived |
| Outputs | Base DSCR | 0.60x | Derived |
| Outputs | Downside DSCR (SDE -20%) | 0.33x | Derived |
| Outputs | Annual shortfall | -100,624 | Derived |
| Outputs | Debt-supported ceiling | 569,000 | Derived |